好文集ChatGPT Plus¥119

Is Crypto VC Dead?

Was at an LP dinner a few days back, with $15 billion dollars represented in the room, and the biggest topic of the night was the sudden shift from crypto to frontier tech. Everyone was trying to understand why this was happening, whether crypto was still investable, and some were thrown off by how quickly major players in the industry were making the move.

A few takeaways from the discussion and some of my own thoughts.

Historically, early talent flows into new industries. Think of Chris Dixon's night and weekend archetypal founders, the ones willing to take 10x career risk to explore something new. These are generally the founders who create entirely new markets, and it's also where some of the highest multiples are made.

Crypto was no different. Over the past decade we've seen thousands of experiments, and the ones that found PMF have carved out their respective markets. But the opportunity set has changed. Today much of the onchain industry is increasingly focused on Wall Street, TradFi, payments and fintech. These are massive markets with much bigger TAMs, but they're also much more focused industries compared to the perceived opportunity in crypto back in 2020/21.

We also have to remember that much of crypto's growth happened during the ZIRP era. Every new chain, token and narrative that launched during that period gave us the perception that we were correct about where the future was headed. Token prices went up, and we assumed the thesis was playing out. But as it turned out, things didn't play out exactly that way.

In parallel, multiple industries started gaining traction, AI, robotics, physical AI etc. Some of the early spotters like Alex Atallah recognized this shift and moved into AI, which turned out to be the correct move at the time.

If we think of the 2020s as the frontier tech decade, it arguably started with crypto, followed by AI, robotics and physical AI, and will likely end with biotech and materials science getting much more attention. Eventually all of these industries will intertwine in some shape or form.

And funny enough, we're seeing the same patterns repeat themselves. AI only pods, AI only white paper groups, robotics only white paper groups, founders spending their nights and weekends exploring these upcoming sectors. We saw the exact same thing in the early days of crypto if you remember. And IMO what I have learned from the early days of crypto is that all of the new talent gravitated towards this space specifically because it was new and exciting. And the way I see it now, it's multiple new sectors all happening at the same time, which I believe will converge later in the future.

Crypto is now dealing with a few things in parallel, competing for talent density against newer sectors, recovering from zirp, shedding its broader web3 narrative to become more Wall Street and fintech focused and new technological impact e.g AI or Quantum.

Were also seeing a phenomenal similar to AI where its easy for larger incumbents to use existing distribution to adopt stables and other onchain infra which makes it harder for startups to compete against. So were seeing startups get acquired, merge or pivot into other areas which may seem bearish but its healthy.

So the prevailing question is where is the opportunity?

Naturally one of the LPs asked, do we still need crypto VCs?

After a bunch of back and forth, the general consensus was yes, but probably not for much longer. We may have one or potentially two more cycles before crypto fully merges into the broader frontier tech market.

Some may view this negatively, but I think it's extremely positive. It shows that crypto is maturing as an industry and that the broader tech market has effectively validated much of what we've been building. A lot of fintech and AI-only companies and new founders still need extensive crypto expertise, and that expertise is mostly concentrated within crypto-native talent and VCs. I also think we're on the cusp of another major shift.

Crypto was the first of many frontier tech sectors to get started, but then went into a period of stagnation. It then helped fintech find new opps via stablecoins, tokenization and onchain infra. Now with AI maturing, we're starting to see AI forward companies adopt crypto infra via agentic payments, wallets and agentic trading.

It's likely we haven't yet uncovered new opportunities in the space because there are so many frontier tech sectors that have yet to emerge, and each one could become a hidden catalyst for the next wave of crypto adoption.

And I think we're underestimating how much of crypto's future growth will come from sectors that haven't yet matured. We haven't seen defi or agentic brokerages reach millions of users yet, or tokenized stocks penetrate emerging markets.

I've said this many times but if a typical new tech paradigm takes roughly 30 years to mature, I think of it in three phases. The first 1/3 is where the highest multiples are made, the second 1/3 is where the most money is made, and the final 1/3 is where the industry consolidates around the winners. I think we're in the second phase of this shift.

Now why are major crypto VCs suddenly moving into frontier tech?

Outside of everything mentioned above, I think the answer is pretty straightforward from a fund perspective. The opportunity set in crypto is narrower than what we believed it was in 2020. You can't meaningfully deploy $1B-$3B into crypto only today and expect the same returns. From a fund mathematics perspective, a $2B fund targeting 3x needs to return $6B, which means you need multiple $10B-$50B outcomes with meaningful ownership to make the math work.

Historically one of the few categories you could underwrite at that scale was L1s and other infrastructure based projects. But as the industry matures and more value accrues to apps with distribution or existing companies with distribution, it becomes difficult to justify funds of that size focused exclusively on crypto.

So it makes perfect sense for these firms to expand into robotics, physical AI, compute and other frontier tech. They need a broader opportunity set to deploy capital and generate venture scale returns. They can get meaningful ownership, and the markups in current venture rounds have a feasible path to an IPO, just look at some of the AI and robotics companies today.

So what happens with domain specific VCs? They will continue to have an edge, similar to fintech VCs or vertical specific VCs in other industries, but we simply don't need as many of them over time. We're just now shedding the excess from previous cycles, while the firms that are left are either doubling down on their focus or broadening their focus to include frontier tech.

There's also the talent question.

We're definitely feeling the migration of younger technical talent into AI and robotics. Historically this was the talent that would have been reading crypto white papers by Dan Boneh and then going on to build a protocol, but that talent is now flowing elsewhere. But that doesn't mean we're going through a brain drain. From Alliance's data alone, we're seeing a large number of existing crypto talent leaving large companies and going out on their own to build startups, more so than younger talent.

So what does all of this mean at the end of the day?

Crypto and onchain will always be an industry, but it's becoming much more focused on finance, payments and financial infra. We still have a ton of time for these products to mature and reach billions of people, and we're nowhere close to that today. What I found most interesting from the dinner was that LPs weren't bearish on crypto. They were excited about crypto growing up, becoming intertwined with new sectors that could bring entirely new opportunities and effectively doubling down on those with a long time horizon on crypto.

全文完
查看原文